Crittenton Women’s Union Cites Failings in State’s Ed System
March 12, 2008 — Nearly half of the state’s 3.2 million workers lack the skills required by employers to obtain jobs with family-sustaining wages, according to a report released today from Crittenton Women’s Union, a Boston-based nonprofit that helps low-income women attain economic independence.
The report, Unlocking the Doors to Higher Education and Training for Massachusetts’ Working Poor Families, says Massachusetts must change its educational system to provide hundreds of thousands of low-income working adults more opportunity to gain the skills they need to secure family-supporting jobs in today’s knowledge-based economy.
It details significant problems in the state’s educational system that impede low-income working adults—specifically those supporting themselves and their families—from embarking on and paying for higher education.
“Across Massachusetts are families that are working hard to support themselves, but the breadwinners lack the educational levels they need to compete in today’s economy,” said Elisabeth D. Babcock, president and CEO of Crittenton Women’s Union and one of the report’s authors.
“Those who have the most to gain are women. Seventy-two percent of families living below the federal poverty line in our state are headed by single mothers. Women with an associate’s degree earn 47% more than those with a high school diploma, while for men the gain is 30%. With the state requiring a stronger workforce to remain economically competitive, we have to act now to give these workers—both men and women—a better chance to obtain post-secondary education and develop skills they need.”
The report calls for more financial aid, better counseling and a more-coordinated education system to meet the needs of low-income working adults.
It also notes that an increasing number of family-supporting jobs in the state require some post-secondary education. However, according to the report, Massachusetts has more than 1.4 million people between the ages of 25 and 54 who do not have an associate’s degree or higher level of educational attainment.
The report focuses on the state’s 117,000 low-income working families, defined as those who earn less than 200% of the federal poverty income threshold (or $33,200 for a family of three in 2006). Despite having a working adult in the home, these families earn too little to make ends meet or gain economic security. For these workers, skills training provides the surest way to better jobs, but such education is often unaffordable and unmanageable for working adults.
In addition, the report finds that the state’s basic educational offerings for adults—geared to students without a high school diploma or GED—are poorly funded and do a poor job of preparing students to move directly into careers or into higher education courses, the main goals of many adult students.
Recommendations for Policymakers
The report makes recommendations in four key areas to state policymakers:- Provide two years of community college instruction at no cost, with priority given to low-income working adults. The state should also consider tuition incentives to adults who complete classes and obtain a GED.
- Provide career counseling, guidance and support – including increased childcare assistance – for adult, or nontraditional, students.
- Make permanent and increase funding for the Educational Awards Grant and Loan Programs, which assist part-time adult students. Eligibility for these funds should be expanded to allow more working adults to qualify.
- Align the K-12 and higher education systems to make it easier for students to transition from high school into college-level courses. This should include the creation of a council to better coordinate the state’s offering of adult education, college-level and remedial classes.
The Crittenton Women’s Union has studied the cost of living across the state and developed the Massachusetts Family Economic Self-Sufficiency Standard, which indicates that, depending on where they live in the state, a family of three requires an income of between 266% to 350% of poverty level, or between $44,000 and $58,000 annually, to afford basic needs without public assistance.
“This means that in our state working poor adults with families not only can’t make ends meet, but they also can’t access programs that would help them get the education they need to lift them out of poverty,” Babcock said.
The report was written by Crittenton Women’s Union, with support from the Working Poor Families Project, a national initiative supported by the Annie E. Casey, Ford, Joyce and Mott Foundations. The Working Poor Families Project examines state policies that affect low-income working families and recommends changes to strengthen those policies and create more economic opportunity.
To view the full report, click here.